Overview
This article appeared in The Newtonian, Issue #41, Autumn 2026
THE FRAMEWORK
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(f)(3) permits service abroad by “other means not prohibited by international agreement, as the court orders.” The Hague Service Convention is such an agreement, and compliance with it “is mandatory in all cases to which it applies.” The Convention does not apply, however, “where the address of the person to be served with the document is not known.”
China, where many Schedule A defendants are based, has objected to the alternative methods in Article 10, including service by postal channels, and service through its Central Authority can take a year or more. Schedule A plaintiffs have therefore routinely sought ex parte orders authorizing email service, on one of two theories: the defendants’ addresses are unknown, so the Convention does not apply; or, even if it applies, it does not expressly prohibit email. Many courts accepted one or both.
Smart Study and Kangol: Email Service in China Barred Where Convention Applies
On December 18, 2025, the Second Circuit rejected the second theory in Smart Study Co. v. Shenzhenshixindajixieyouxiangongsi, the “Baby Shark” counterfeiting case. Writing for the panel, Judge Richard J. Sullivan explained that the Convention “‘create[s]’ a closed universe of ‘simple and certain means’” of serving parties abroad, so that email service on defendants in China is prohibited whenever the Convention applies, and he declined to read an emergency exception into Rule 4(f)(3). The court acknowledged the difficulty of policing infringement in China, but decided that the Convention “was not designed to ensure that the service of process in China is as efficient and fast as domestic service in the United States,” and Smart Study “has not even attempted to comply with the Convention’s requirements.”
On May 29, 2026, the Seventh Circuit, whose Northern District of Illinois hears more Schedule A cases than any other court, followed suit in Kangol LLC v. Hangzhou Chuanyue Silk Import & Export Co. The facts did not favor the defendant. It had contacted the plaintiff the day it received an email linking to the complaint, negotiated for the better part of a year, including after a default judgment was entered against it, and appeared in court only after the plaintiff collected from its Amazon account. Rejecting the district court’s contrary reading, Judge Kirsch wrote for the panel: “We conclude the opposite; the Convention prohibits email service in China.”
The court reversed the denial of the motion to vacate and remanded for a finding on whether the defendant’s address was “not known,” and thus whether the Convention applied at all. The motion was timely, the court held, because the defendant sought relief within two months of collection, and months of settlement talks had not waived the objection.
How Are District Courts Applying Smart Study and Kangol?
Some judgments already entered are being unwound. In Deckers Outdoor Corp. v. A AO and Deckers Outdoor Corp. v. Litfun, two Northern District of Illinois judges vacated default judgments against Amazon sellers because the plaintiff had not shown reasonably diligent efforts to locate or verify their addresses before seeking email service. As Judge Bucklo put it, “bare assertions regarding the reliability of [a defendant’s] publicly available address are not a substitute for actual diligence.”
Judge Simon of the Northern District of Indiana likewise rejected an investigator’s after-the-fact declaration in Messika Group as “too little, too late.” He did not dismiss the case, however; he directed the plaintiff to serve the defendant under the Convention.
Standing orders now demand the same defendant-specific showings. The District of New Jersey adopted that approach in September 2025, before either appellate ruling; Judge Gettleman’s September 2026 standing order in the Northern District of Illinois requires plaintiffs to explain their basis for service early in the case.
When Is Email Service Still Allowed?
Still, email service is not gone; two openings remain. The first is the Convention’s own: where a plaintiff has searched diligently and cannot locate or verify an address, the Convention does not apply. In Global Brother SRL v. Zhuliang, the Middle District of Florida authorized email service after China’s Central Authority reported that the supplied address “does not exist” and diligent efforts turned up no other.
Urgency is the second opening, and a narrower one. In Fox Corp. v. Media Deportes Mexico, S. de R.L. de C.V., Judge Rakoff relied on Article 15(3), which permits “provisional or protective measures” in cases of urgency, to uphold temporary injunctive relief and related contempt sanctions despite incomplete Convention service, distinguishing Smart Study as a case about a final default judgment. The reasoning supports email service of interim relief; it does not make email sufficient for a default judgment.
Outside the Second and Seventh Circuits, the question remains open. For example, on September 11, 2026, the Northern District of California authorized email service on a Chinese company in NETGEAR, Inc. v. Elitecom Technologies Corp., noting that “[t]here is no Ninth Circuit precedent on this issue.”
Where the Courts Stand (as of October 2026)
| Court | Decision or order | Position on email service in China |
|---|---|---|
| Second Circuit | Smart Study (Dec. 18, 2025) | Prohibited where the Convention applies |
| Seventh Circuit | Kangol (May 29, 2026) | Prohibited where the Convention applies |
| N.D. Ill. | Deckers v. A AO; Deckers v. Litfun (2026) | Default judgments vacated without a diligent address search |
| N.D. Ind. | Messika Group (Aug. 24, 2026) | After-the-fact diligence rejected; Convention service ordered |
| M.D. Fla. | Global Brother (Mar. 25, 2026) | Allowed after China’s Central Authority reported the address did not exist |
| S.D.N.Y. | Fox Corp. (2026) | Interim relief upheld under Article 15(3) despite incomplete Convention service |
| N.D. Cal. | NETGEAR (Sept. 11, 2026) | Allowed; no Ninth Circuit precedent |
| D.N.J.; N.D. Ill. | Standing orders (Sept. 2025; Sept. 2026) | Defendant-specific showing required |
| Fifth Circuit | Nagravision (2018) | Upheld (decided before Smart Study) |
What Comes Next for Schedule A Litigation
Taken together, Smart Study and Kangol do not end Schedule A litigation, but they do end the era in which service was an afterthought. Rights holders should plan, document, and budget for service from the outset. Defendants should review the service record promptly: defects may justify challenging a default judgment or related enforcement measures, even if the emailed papers reached them.
INSIGHTS
1. What Should Rights Holders Do?
- Building the diligence record. Document the efforts made to locate and/or verify each defendant’s address and put that evidence in the motion for alternative service. (Courts have refused to credit investigations undertaken only after the defendant challenged service.)
- Convention service should start early. Delay does not make a prohibited method permissible, and a request sent promptly preserves an important option: the Convention allows a default judgment without a certificate of service once at least six months have passed since transmission by a Convention method and reasonable efforts to obtain a certificate have failed. A waiver-of-service request costs little and may avoid service altogether.
- A domestic route may take the Convention out of the picture. Service on U.S. counsel or a U.S. affiliate avoids the Convention only if governing law or a court order authorizes it, and service is complete in the United States; representation or affiliation by itself is not enough.
- Interim relief and final judgment are different questions. Some courts permit email service of a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction; that does not mean the same service will support a default judgment, and in the Second and Seventh Circuits email service on a defendant in China will not where the Convention applies.
2. What Should Defendants Do?
- Service comes before the merits. Where the Convention applies, improper email service may support a motion to vacate a default judgment, so preserve service and personal-jurisdiction objections at the first opportunity. A request to dissolve asset restraints should also address whether the restraints stand independently as interim relief.
- The window to object. In Kangol and both Deckers cases, challenges filed weeks or months after judgment were timely, and months of settlement talks did not waive the objection in Kangol. Such motions must still be brought within a reasonable time, and the clock does not necessarily wait for collection to begin.
- Accurate listings protect the objection. A Convention-based challenge turns on whether reasonably diligent efforts could have located or verified the defendant’s address when alternative service was requested; a false or outdated listing weakens the objection even if it does not automatically make the address “not known.” Ensure that marketplace listings and business records are current.