This article appeared in The Newtonian, Issue #41, Autumn 2026

Over five years ago, RiseandShine Corporation (“Rise”) sued PepsiCo, Inc. (“Pepsi”) in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, alleging that Pepsi’s new MTN DEW RISE ENERGY drink infringed on its RISE coffee products. After multiple appeals and remands between the district court and the Second Circuit, the Supreme Court has agreed to review what Rise characterizes as a significant circuit split concerning the determination of inherent trademark strength in the likelihood of confusion analysis, namely, “[w]hether trademark strength is a question of fact in a likelihood-of-confusion analysis under 15 U.S.C. § 1114.”

Trademark strength is one part of a multifactor likelihood-of-confusion analysis and is evaluated through two lenses: inherent (or “conceptual”) strength and commercial strength. Commercial strength represents how well a mark is known in the marketplace. Inherent strength is the degree to which the mark itself is distinctive in relation to the goods or services it is used in connection with.

According to Rise, the overwhelming majority of federal circuits treat inherent trademark strength as a factual issue for a jury to decide, while the Second Circuit treats it as a legal question for a judge to decide. Unsurprisingly, Rise advocates for the former approach, arguing that inherent trademark strength should be determined by a factfinder, rather than resolved as a matter of law by a judge. That position is significant for Rise because both the district court and the Second Circuit found that its RISE mark was conceptually weak for coffee as a matter of law. Pepsi opposed the Supreme Court’s review, but the Supreme Court granted the petition for certiorari on June 29, 2026.

The Supreme Court’s resolution of the question presented could have significant implications for trademark litigation and brand development moving forward. A finding that inherent trademark strength is a question of fact would more frequently require a jury determination, thereby increasing the time and money spent on reaching a conclusion. On the other hand, a finding that inherent trademark strength is a question of law would see that issue more frequently decided pre-trial, on summary judgment. Some litigants may favor the efficiency of a judge-decided legal question, while others may favor the opportunity to present evidence of consumer perception and marketplace context to a jury; the optimal approach will depend on strategic and fact-based considerations unique to each dispute. Either way, companies will have a stronger incentive to adopt inherently distinctive marks and devote additional resources to cultivating the commercial strength of those marks.

A number of industry organizations and academics have weighed in on the question via amicus briefs, providing detailed analyses on the question presented. A summary of these parties and their respective positions is included in the chart below.

Amicus Brief FilerIn Support OfPosition
Assistant Professor Thomas A. ReichertNeither PartyArgues that assessing a factor is factual work while composing factor findings into an outcome is legal work.
Intellectual Property Owners AssociationNeither PartyArgues that strength determinations present a mixed question of both law and fact, but that the legal component should be treated as predominant.
Professor Sepehr ShahshahaniNeither PartyArgues that the Court should emphasize that judges should play a prominent role in answering the question of strength.
American Intellectual Property Law Association (“AIPLA”)Suggesting ReversalArgues in support of conceptual strength being a question of fact.
International Trademark Association (“INTA”)Neither PartyArgues in support of trademark strength being a question of fact when a jury trial has been requested and summary judgment or judgment as a matter of law are not at issue.
Trademark Law ScholarsNeither PartyArgues that this is a mixed question of law and fact that should not be treated as a purely factual question.
The United StatesSupporting VacaturArgues that strength determinations present a mixed question of both law and fact, but that the legal component should be treated as predominant.

We will continue to monitor the RiseandShine Corporation v. PepsiCo, Inc. case, and its potential impact on brand development and trademark enforcement. Check back for our analysis after the Supreme Court issues its decision!